
When an elected official controls the mechanism that sets his own paycheck, the arrangement survives only as long as the public trusts his judgment — and in Babylon, New York, that trust had already been spent elsewhere, long before anyone opened the 2027 budget.
Key Points
- Babylon’s preliminary 2027 budget proposed raising Supervisor Rich Schaffer’s salary from $123,680 to $160,000 — a 29.3% increase — alongside a near-6% property tax hike.
- Schaffer, who also chairs the Suffolk County Democratic Party, is under FBI investigation tied to alleged vote-buying, a fact residents repeatedly invoked during public hearings.
- More than three dozen residents spoke against the raise and tax increase at a town budget hearing, citing both the timing and Schaffer’s legal exposure.
- Schaffer reversed course after the backlash, telling Newsday “message received” and committing to a pay cut rather than a raise.
- New York law treats a town supervisor’s salary as an incident of the office, set by board resolution — not a personal entitlement — a distinction that shaped how residents framed their objections.
What Was Proposed, and Why It Drew Immediate Fire
The mechanics were straightforward enough on paper. Babylon’s preliminary 2027 budget, unveiled October 15, set Supervisor Rich Schaffer’s salary at $160,000, up from $123,680 — a jump of $36,320, or roughly 29 to 30% depending on how the figure was rounded across different outlets. The same budget proposed a property tax increase that various reports placed between 5.8% and nearly 6%. Schaffer, who holds the unusual dual role of Babylon town supervisor and chairman of the Suffolk County Democratic Party, said publicly that the Town Board would make the final decision in January and that he personally would abstain from voting on his own raise.
That procedural detail — his pledge not to vote on it himself — did little to blunt the optics. Schaffer has been under federal investigation tied to allegations of vote manipulation, a fact that colored nearly every objection raised at the subsequent public hearing. Residents did not treat the raise as an abstract budgeting line item. They treated it as a test of whether a town government under an active FBI cloud should be asking taxpayers to fund a near-30% pay bump for the official at the center of that cloud.
How Salary-Setting Actually Works in a New York Town
It helps to understand the legal architecture behind the controversy, because it is not as loose as “the boss gave himself a raise” implies. Under New York Town Law § 27, the town board — not the supervisor alone — fixes the salaries of town officers, and that authority is bounded by procedural requirements: changes generally must appear in the preliminary budget’s public notice before a hearing, and a sitting board cannot simply inflate pay outside that process. The state comptroller has repeatedly opined that a town officer’s salary is legally “an incident of the office” rather than a personal entitlement tied to the individual holding it, meaning the position carries the pay rate, not the person. Case law has reinforced that boards can even reduce salaries by resolution, within limits, and that compensation disputes are adjudicated as matters of municipal procedure, not personal grievance.
This matters because it explains why the proposal could move as far as it did — formally, properly, documented in a preliminary budget — while still provoking the reaction it got. The process was not secret or improper on its face. Resolution No. 37, passed by the Town Board on January 5, 2026, had already fixed Schaffer’s prior-year salary at $123,679, establishing the baseline the new figure would have nearly doubled in percentage terms over two cycles of adjustment. The legality of the mechanism and the political wisdom of using it are two separate questions, and Babylon residents made clear they were judging the latter, not litigating the former.
The Hearing, the Backlash, and the Reversal
At the budget hearing, the criticism was specific, named, and repeated. Karen Scribner told the board bluntly, “I just don’t understand how someone can give themselves a 29% raise”. Copiague resident Jackie Burbridge connected the raise directly to the federal scrutiny: residents were being asked to fund a salary increase “as you are actively being investigated by the federal and state for corruption charges”. Deer Park resident Joseph Prevete pressed on timing, asking how officials could justify a raise for themselves “when things are so, everybody’s so strapped for cash”, while Kristin Schuster objected to a separate but related pattern — Babylon’s recurring practice of exceeding the state’s property tax cap, which she argued should be an occasional emergency measure, not a routine budgeting tool. More than thirty speakers raised similar objections across the hearing.
Babylon Town Supervisor Rich Schaffer says he will take a pay cut instead of a proposed 29% raise following backlash from residents.
Schaffer’s salary was set to increase from $123,680 to $160,000 under the proposed 2027 budget. He now says he will reduce his salary to $120,000.… pic.twitter.com/2cJisGTZwx
— Newsday (@Newsday) November 13, 2026
The reversal followed quickly. Schaffer told Newsday “message received” and said he would not accept the increase, instead taking a pay cut to roughly $120,000 — about $3,700 below his prior salary — while the board stripped the other proposed elected-official raises from the budget entirely. “I’m serious about the challenges we face, so I cut my salary for next year,” he said. Whatever one makes of the FBI investigation’s eventual outcome — and an investigation, however serious, remains an allegation rather than a finding of wrongdoing — the sequence of events here is not in dispute: a documented proposal, a documented public hearing, and a documented retreat, all captured in town records and multiple independent outlets.
A Structural Problem the Town Will Face Again
Babylon’s episode is a clean illustration of a tension that recurs in municipal government nationwide: officials need enough pay to make public service viable for people who aren’t independently wealthy, yet the people who set that pay are often the same people who benefit from it, or their close colleagues. Scholarship on elected-official compensation identifies two opposite failure modes — self-dealing that inflates salaries beyond public tolerance, and “reverse ratcheting,” where officials keep pay artificially low out of fear of exactly the backlash Babylon just saw, discouraging qualified candidates from running at all [research on council compensation]. Babylon’s board will revisit this salary question in January, as Schaffer himself acknowledged, and the underlying structural question — how a town insulates routine compensation decisions from the appearance of self-interest — will still be unresolved, FBI probe or not.
Sources:
nypost.com, us.headtopics.com, townofbabylonny.gov, newsday.com, ilovebabylon.com, orleansparishherald.com, hudsonvalley.news12.com



